Carl, you big jerk. Had to go touch a deer, did you? You realize this has now turned the plot around in a million different ways? You've done a super job is stealing the show and making your characters do things they never would've done before. Oh, how you've elevated this plot line and challenged its characters to flip the needs of their development. Le Sigh, Carl. Don't you feel just great about yourself? Hold on - let's dial this back. We should be thanking this little monkey for picking up the pieces of a slow start to the second season of
The Walking Dead. Without him, we'd still be watching Andrea roll her eyes at not-her-father Dale and searching for an already assumed dead little girl in the woods. High five, Carl.

So, I'll start with the most obvious plot point: Shane's gone all GI Jane, has he not? Wow. I didn't see that coming at all. For once the show has stopped playing it safe. I for one, enjoyed the lack of precaution this episode took. For once, it's not just how a zombie could bite someone else that has me sitting rigid. What the show needed was some good old fashioned character development. Shane has now left a man behind and what's more, was the cause of it. What you think would be a normal "turns out we made it!" run to the high school has led to poor, poor Otis being shot in the leg and left for dead. Not only did Shane shoot him, but he wrestled him to the ground then proceeded to look back at him being torn limb from limb by thirsty zombies. Wowee, does he have some s'plaining to do.
The group is now divided between the farm house and the highway. Rick and Lori are sitting by Carl's bed hoping for a miracle and trading Shane stories as they wait for he and Otis to return with a respirator to perform Carl's surgery. Andrea and Daryl bond while disappearing into the dark woods and shining their flashlights on everything while a concerned Dale awaits them on the highway.
T-Dog and Glenn arrive at the farm house to seek medical attention for T-Dog's injured arm. Aside from the blossoming romance between Glenn and the new girl Maggie, my favorite part of this exchange is Maggie's question: "Did you lock the gate?" The gate? Oh, so that's what's keeping the zombies away from their 10 acre farm. The
GATE! Ah, it all makes sense now. It's the
gate that's allowed them to sit on the porch and avoid this whole end of the world thing. The
gate is the reason that all the zombies in Georgia aren't allowed to ruin this beautiful Little House of the Prairie scenario. How smart! If only other would-be survivors could take a cue from this genius group of renegade zombie killers... Build a GATE! I can think of so many movies now whose outcome would've been so much different had they only had the foresight to build a f*#king GATE!
Jaws? Carrie? Night of the Living Dead? Any space movie ever made?
GATES!
What gave me pause, however, was the mystifying way in which Lori spoke of the fate of her son. When questioning whether or not they'd like to proceed with Carl's surgery, Lori wasn't sure if they should. She wondered if the kind of world they live in was suitable for children and that maybe Carl's death was a better option. While a part of me could understand that mentality when faced with an environment overrun with zombies, I'm not convinced that Rick's job should've been to convince her to believe in life again. How ridiculous was it that Rick essentially leaves it up to her in the end as to whether or not they're going to operate on Carl? I imagine that it had everything to do with wanting her to say, "Life is beautiful even if we're all going to be eaten soon - let's save him!" But in the end, that's still your son! You're still the father! That's your job, man! Yet I'm enjoying the fact that the deer has remained in the forefront of this story for a good three episodes.
The episode itself was eloquently timed, performed and executed. The story line with Shane should only get more interesting from here and I look forward to seeing how dark they can take him. (Having accidentally seen a spoiler online, I have a good feeling I know where Shane will go...) Carl? Well, Carl will definitely live. Think of the deer! Think of what we're fighting for! And for Sophia - wait, who is Sophia?